| 1. | 4. | 14. | Findlay | John Carroll | Malone | A | A | A | Milani Glass, Maud Sanmiquel, Samantha Grippe, Laura Hernandez | Sarah Koch, Chelsey Seifert, Michaela Hermes, Katy Foltz | Alyssa Biedron, Joy Nyaanga, Sara Martinko, Noelle Saluan | 3:57.40 | 4:07.0487 | 3:57.40 |
| 2. | 15. | 14. | Malone | John Carroll (C) | Cornerstone (B) | A | C | B | Crystal Barber, Hannah Boss, Taryn Chapman, Erika Rector | Alyssa Biedron, Joy Nyaanga, Sara Martinko, Noelle Saluan | Sara Lehman, Jessica Swisher, Ashura Powell, Cassie Schillero | 16:04:06.50 | 44:04:23.53 | 4:31.050 |
| 3. | 8. | 13. | John Carroll | Otterbein | Otterbein (B) | A | A | A | Alyssa Biedron, Joy Nyaanga, Sara Martinko, Noelle Saluan | Sarah Koch, Chelsey Seifert, Michaela Hermes, Katy Foltz | Alyssa Biedron, Joy Nyaanga, Sara Martinko, Noelle Saluan | 4:07.0487 | 4:18.71 | 4:55.334 |
| 4. | 10. | 14. | Cornerstone | Capital (B) | Bluffton (B) | A | B | A | Makayla Clum, Kaitlyn Bronkema, Megan Quick, Lyndee Zeigler | Alyssa Biedron, Joy Nyaanga, Sara Martinko, Noelle Saluan | Gabrielle Genovesi, Samantha Koester, Mackenzie Meyers, Hannah Westhoven | 4:07.22 | 10:04:25.670 | 16:04:22.52 |
| 5. | 2. | 16. | Otterbein | Capital (B) | Malone | A | A | A | Sarah Koch, Chelsey Seifert, Michaela Hermes, Katy Foltz | Katie Grimes, Ashley Krieger, Corrina Ruffener, Emily O'Dell | Alyssa Biedron, Joy Nyaanga, Sara Martinko, Noelle Saluan | 42:04:15.27 | 42:04:15.27 | 11:04:23.012 |
| 6. | 3. | 16. | Bluffton | John Carroll | Bluffton | A | B | A | Terrill Webb, Devony Miller, Hannah Krull, Sarah Hunter | Madison Gleckler, Valerie Richter, Ally Rabe, Joy Reist | Milani Glass, Maud Sanmiquel, Samantha Grippe, Laura Hernandez | 4:18.71 | 4:07.0487 | 16:04:22.52 |
| 7. | 6. | 13. | Cornerstone (B) | Heidelberg | Bowling Green Track Club | B | A | A | Madison Gleckler, Valerie Richter, Ally Rabe, Joy Reist | Kristin Schiefer, Miranda Hostettler, Alissa Hauke, Jennie Matteson | , , , , | 16:04:22.52 | 34:04:56.56 | 4:07.22 |
| 8. | 16. | 7. | Capital | Heidelberg | Malone | A | A | A | Larkin Joseph, Shaylynn Dornbush, MacKenzie Ciganick, Caitlyn Tulloss | Sarah Koch, Chelsey Seifert, Michaela Hermes, Katy Foltz | Alainna Schmidt, Emma Harvey, Christine Smith, Crystal Hajek | 11:04:23.012 | 34:04:56.56 | 32:04:44.3283 |
| 9. | 3. | 5. | Malone (B) | Bluffton (B) | Bluffton | B | A | C | Katie Grimes, Ashley Krieger, Corrina Ruffener, Emily O'Dell | Alyssa Biedron, Joy Nyaanga, Sara Martinko, Noelle Saluan | Harley Berlesky, Alexandra Chakov, Alexandra Dutton, Nicole Tennison | 44:04:23.53 | 4:18.71 | 4:55.334 |
| 10. | 14. | 16. | John Carroll (B) | Cornerstone (B) | Findlay | B | A | B | Sara Lehman, Jessica Swisher, Ashura Powell, Cassie Schillero | Sarah Koch, Chelsey Seifert, Michaela Hermes, Katy Foltz | Larkin Joseph, Shaylynn Dornbush, MacKenzie Ciganick, Caitlyn Tulloss | 4:24.6005 | 4:18.71 | 4:24.6005 |
| 11. | 15. | 16. | Otterbein (B) | John Carroll (B) | Bluffton | B | A | B | Sarah Bedell, Alexis Snyder, Lindsey Jones, Becca Gallagher | Alainna Schmidt, Emma Harvey, Christine Smith, Crystal Hajek | Makayla Clum, Kaitlyn Bronkema, Megan Quick, Lyndee Zeigler | 10:04:25.670 | 4:31.050 | 4:07.22 |
| 12. | 8. | 4. | John Carroll (C) | Capital | Malone (B) | C | A | A | Alainna Schmidt, Emma Harvey, Christine Smith, Crystal Hajek | , , , , | Katie Grimes, Ashley Krieger, Corrina Ruffener, Emily O'Dell | 4:31.050 | 4:07.22 | 3:57.40 |
| 13. | 1. | 10. | Heidelberg | Bowling Green Track Club | John Carroll (C) | A | A | A | Harley Berlesky, Alexandra Chakov, Alexandra Dutton, Nicole Tennison | Madison Gleckler, Valerie Richter, Ally Rabe, Joy Reist | , , , , | 32:04:44.3283 | 4:18.71 | 4:07.22 |
| 14. | 8. | 14. | Bowling Green Track Club | John Carroll (B) | Cornerstone (B) | A | C | B | , , , , | Katie Grimes, Ashley Krieger, Corrina Ruffener, Emily O'Dell | Terrill Webb, Devony Miller, Hannah Krull, Sarah Hunter | 4:55.334 | 4:31.050 | 10:04:25.670 |
| 15. | 1. | 13. | Capital (B) | John Carroll | Otterbein | B | B | A | Gabrielle Genovesi, Samantha Koester, Mackenzie Meyers, Hannah Westhoven | , , , , | Sarah Bedell, Alexis Snyder, Lindsey Jones, Becca Gallagher | 34:04:56.56 | 4:31.050 | 11:04:23.012 |
| 16. | 3. | 2. | Bluffton (B) | Capital (B) | Otterbein | B | A | A | Kristin Schiefer, Miranda Hostettler, Alissa Hauke, Jennie Matteson | Alyssa Biedron, Joy Nyaanga, Sara Martinko, Noelle Saluan | Alyssa Biedron, Joy Nyaanga, Sara Martinko, Noelle Saluan | 4:59.176 | 4:31.050 | 42:04:15.27 |
